Pete's Tavern: A Gramercy Park Institution Since 1864

What's your favorite New York City bar? Seriously, I want to know. Email me! Pete's Tavern might not be my all time favorite, but it's certainly up there. I love that it hides in plain sight, still going strong, serving great food and drinks while preserving that timeless New York City atmosphere.

Tucked away on the corner of Irving Place and East 18th Street, Pete's Tavern proudly claims to be New York City's oldest continuously operating bar. Of course, McSorley's Old Ale House makes a similar claim. So who's right? I'll let you decide.

The building dates back to 1829, when it was constructed as the Portman Hotel. By 1864, a grocery and grog store was operating on the ground floor, establishing the drinking tradition that continues at this corner today.

In 1899, brothers Tom and John Healy purchased the establishment and renamed it Healy's Café. It quickly became a neighborhood gathering place, attracting everyone from local residents to politicians, writers and businessmen.

Then, in 1922, Peter D'Belles purchased the bar, giving it the name Pete's Tavern, which has remained ever since.

When Prohibition arrived in 1920, drinking establishments across New York were forced to close or find creative ways to survive.

Pete's apparently chose the latter.

According to the tavern's lore, the establishment disguised itself as a flower shop while continuing to serve alcohol to customers who knew where to look. Patrons supposedly entered through a side door, provided a password and were escorted through a disguised refrigerator door into the hidden drinking establishment. Remarkably, the hinges from that old doorway are said to remain in the building today.

And with Tammany Hall nearby, there's long been speculation that local politicians and officials were willing to look the other way.

One of Pete's most famous patrons was William Sydney Porter, better known by his pen name, O. Henry. The celebrated short story writer lived in the neighborhood from 1903 to 1907 and became a regular at what was then Healy's Café.

According to local legend, it was here that he wrote The Gift of the Magi, his beloved Christmas story about a young couple who each sacrifice their most treasured possession to buy a gift for the other.

A brass plaque inside the tavern commemorates the connection, ensuring that O. Henry remains part of Pete's history more than a century later.

Over the decades, Pete's has welcomed an eclectic collection of New Yorkers, from politicians and journalists to Broadway actors, artists, tourists and neighborhood regulars. The tavern has also appeared in films and television shows, although what I find most remarkable is how much of its original character remains.

Step inside and you'll find beautiful old woodwork, antique lighting and a magnificent 40 foot rosewood bar. It's the kind of place where you can almost imagine the conversations that have taken place over the past century and a half.

And while Pete's is worth visiting any time of year, there's something particularly special about it during the holidays. The entire place transforms into a wonderfully festive New York destination, with decorations covering practically every inch of the interior.

Whether you're looking for a good meal, a pint or simply somewhere to soak up a little New York history, Pete's Tavern is one of those places that reminds me why I love this city.

More than 160 years later, it's still going strong. And I hope it stays that way for another 160.

Chris Baker

Chris Baker is a New York City real estate advisor with Compass and the creator of New York's New York, exploring the homes, history and hidden corners that make this city unlike anywhere else.

https://www.newyorksnewyork.com/contact
Next
Next

McSorley's Old Ale House: History of NYC's Legendary Bar